Peaceful tooth with a purple filling on a purple background


Dental Amalgam Fillings & Replacing Them

Written By : Generations of Smiles Writers

Reviewed By : Charles Rodgers, DDS

Published: Jan 31, 2023

Updated: Nov 17, 2023

In This Article

Good oral hygiene is important because cleaning your teeth helps prevent cavities.

If you do not brush your teeth, bacteria will start feasting on any sugars or starches left between or around your teeth from the foods you eat. This bacteria produces a sticky substance called plaque that creates a thin film over your teeth. You may feel this film on your teeth if you forget to brush your teeth before bed. It can be easily scraped off, but it will eventually harden if not removed within a few days.

Once plaque hardens, it is called tartar or calculus. With a hardened safe haven found in the tartar, bacteria can continue to eat sugars, producing acid that begins to form holes in the enamel of your teeth. This is how a cavity starts to develop. If left untreated, the cavity will likely continue to decay, becoming deeper and possibly painful. Once discovered, a dentist will remove damaged parts of the tooth and fill this hole with a dental filling.

Happy tooth with amalgam filling on on top

What Is a Dental Amalgam Filling (Silver Filling)?

Dental amalgam fillings are made up of several different metals, such as zinc, mercury, tin, silver, and even copper, that a dentist puts into the cavity to seal the hole. This prevents bacteria, food, or saliva from getting inside, causing more decay. Dental amalgam has been used since the turn of the 20th century and continues to be a common dental filling choice.


While silver-colored amalgam is not the only filling option, it has several advantages that other dental fillings do not offer. Some of the benefits of getting a dental amalgam filling are:
  • Affordability: Without insurance, you can expect to pay between $100 and $360 for a tooth to be filled with dental amalgam, depending on how many surfaces of the tooth are affected by decay. Dental amalgam fillings can cost about half as much as composite fillings and even 1/10 as much as gold fillings, making them the most affordable dental filling option.
  • Toughness: Dental amalgam fillings can withstand daily chewing pressure while remaining intact.
  • Durability: Often lasting between 10-15 years, silver-colored amalgam fillings are some of the longest-lasting fillings available.


As with most medical interventions, there can be risks associated with a procedure, and it is important to know these risks, regardless of how rare, so you can make an informed decision. The presence of mercury in dental amalgam fillings causes some people to question their safety. While mercury poisoning is a real thing, the American Dental Association reports that extensive studies have been made to test the safety of the mercury levels in silver amalgam fillings and that the CDC, FDA, and WHO all approve of their use and their safety.

However, it is still reported that about 1% of patients who receive dental amalgam fillings have varying allergic reactions to the mercury in the filling. Other risks include:

  • The amalgam can discolor the rest of the tooth, causing it to turn a grayish color.
  • With hot and cold liquids, the amalgam filling can expand and contract, which can cause the tooth to crack. Amalgam fillings have a higher incidence rate of fracturing in these cases when compared to other cavity fillings.
  • With amalgam fillings, there is a risk of the dentist needing to remove more of the tooth in preparation for receiving the filling.
If you suspect you are having an allergic reaction to your amalgam filling or you have persistent pain or tooth sensitivity around the filling, do not hesitate to get in contact with your dentist right away to discuss replacing the filling with a different type of dental filling.

How Long Does an Amalgam Filling Last?

While no filling is permanent, amalgam fillings can last a long time. Once your dentist fills the cavity, you can expect the filling to last up to 15 years and, in some cases, even longer. However, you may need to have the filling replaced sooner, depending on the size of the cavity. Smaller cavities allow the filling to stay put for longer when compared to larger fillings.
Regular dental visits will help your dentist know when to replace your amalgam filling

Replacing an Amalgam Filling

When a filling reaches its expected longevity, you may develop small cracks in your tooth from the filling expanding and contracting. This lets saliva, food, and bacteria get under the filling and can cause more tooth decay, or you can even develop an abscess. Because of this potential, it should be stressed how important regular appointments with your dentist are. Your dentist will check your fillings at each cleaning so you can be sure no new damage occurs.

If your dentist sees signs that your cavity filling is becoming loose or causing your tooth to crack, they can either replace it or recommend putting a crown over your tooth if the damage is extensive. If you have a filling replaced, you can opt for a different kind of filling if you choose. In general, most dentists do not recommend replacing your dental amalgam filling with a different type of tooth filling unless the lifespan of the amalgam filling has ended.

Alternatives to Amalgam Fillings

Three common alternatives to amalgam fillings are gold, ceramic, and composite fillings. While gold fillings have been the desired option in the past, composite fillings are growing in popularity and continue to improve. Many patients prefer composite fillings because they are enamel colored, making them blend in with the tooth. Although composite fillings are weaker than fillings containing metal, their durability and longevity continue to get better, making them more competitive with other fillings.
Gold fillings are very expensive, but they also have the longest lifespan. They are more aesthetically pleasing than the dark silver of amalgam fillings, but they are not without their possibility for allergic reactions. In fact, if you have a gold filling placed directly near an amalgam filling, it is possible to develop galvanic shock, which causes a sharp pain from an electric reaction between the two metal fillings.
Ceramic fillings are tough and stain-resistant, as well as discreet. In fact, ceramic or porcelain fillings mimic the appearance of your tooth's natural enamel. But they are also about as expensive as gold fillings, making them less affordable for many.

Taking Care of Teeth With Fillings

Directly after you have a cavity filled, your tooth will most likely be sensitive. Your dentist will tell you that you can not eat solid foods for about 24 hours after having an amalgam filling placed in your tooth. Other fillings have different time requirements before they have fully set up. Composite fillings, however, will set while still in the dental chair, so there is no waiting until you can eat after having this type of filling put in.

For a few days, after you get a tooth filling, you should avoid hot or cold liquids that may cause the filling to expand or contract, causing you pain. There is also a potential of dislodging the filling if you begin eating hard or sticky foods too soon. To properly care for a new tooth filling, try your best not to chew with it in the first several days by chewing on the opposite side of your mouth.

After the sensitivity is gone, regular care for your filling is similar to your regular tooth care. Brushing your teeth twice a day and flossing once a day will keep all of your teeth healthy. But with a filling, it is even more important to make sure your dentist lays eyes on your filling every six months to make sure it stays in good shape.

Find a Dentist Near You

If you have a cavity or if you need to replace amalgam fillings, having a dentist you trust is crucial. To find a list of qualified dentists in your area, check out Smile Generation's Find a Dentist tool. Catching a cavity early means less decay. Be sure to make all your dental appointments so you can keep your mouth healthy and your dental fillings in place.


Find your trusted, local dentist today!



"Dental Health and Tooth Fillings." WebMD, 31 Oct. 2021,

"Do I Need To Replace My Amalgam Fillings?" Shine Dental Clinic, 6 June 2019,

"Fillings: Silver-colored." Mouth Healthy, 13 Dec. 2022,

"How to Make Dental Fillings Last Longer?" DentalFreak.Com, 16 Sept. 2021,

"2020 Survey of Dental Fees." American Dental Association, 2020,

Smile Generation blog articles are reviewed by a licensed dental professional before publishing. However, we present this information for educational purposes only with the intent to promote readers’ understanding of oral health and oral healthcare treatment options and technology. We do not intend for our blog content to substitute for professional dental care and clinical advice, diagnosis, or treatment planning provided by a licensed dental professional. Smile Generation always recommends seeking the advice of a dentist, physician, or other licensed healthcare professional for a dental or medical condition or treatment. 

Good oral hygiene is important because cleaning your teeth helps prevent cavities. If you do not brush your teeth, bacteria will start feasting on any sugars or starches left between or around your te
The new year is all about new opportunities, including trying to be a better version of yourself. That can be accomplished in several ways. Some of those involve improving your appearance. Eating heal
The New Year is here, and for many people, that means it’s time to set health-related goals for the coming year. As you’re working on your New Year’s resolution list, consider adding some oral health